Skip to content

Like this? Share it!

  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Email
Closer To Truth
  • Watch
    • Seasons & EpisodesWatch complete episodes as aired on public television
    • Curated PlaylistsExplore collections of videos curated by our team
    • ProjectsDiscover collaborations with leading institutions
    • ContributorsMeet the greatest thinkers exploring the deepest questions
    • CTT ChatsWatch candid conversations with the brightest minds on the boldest ideas
    • Roundtable ArchivesView roundtable discussions from our early years
  • Topics
    • Cosmos, Life, Consciousness, Meaning: Explore the fundamental questions of existence.Topic Guide
    • All Topics
      • CosmosExplore cosmology, physics, and the fundamentals of existence
        • Back
        • All Cosmos
        • Deep Laws of Nature
          • Back
          • All Deep Laws of Nature
          • Cosmic Fundamentals
          • Time and Space-Time
          • Quantum Theory
          • Philosophy of Science
          • Complexity and Emergence
          • Mathematics as Fundamental?
          • Information as Fundamental?
          • Universe as Simulation?
          • Deep Discoveries in Science
        • Vast Cosmos
          • Back
          • All Vast Cosmos
          • Cosmic Immensity
          • Cosmic Beginnings
          • Cosmic Structure
          • Multiple Universes (Multiverse)
          • Black Holes, Dark Energy, Dark Matter
        • Our Special Universe
          • Back
          • All Our Special Universe
          • Fine-Tuning of the Universe?
          • Fine-Tuning the Universe for Life & Mind?
          • Breathtaking Universe
          • Alien Intelligences?
          • Far Future of the Universe
        • Breakthroughs
          • Back
          • All Breakthroughs
          • Breakthroughs in Science
          • Breakthroughs in Mathematics
        • Science and Religion
          • Back
          • All Science and Religion
          • Science vs. Religion?
          • Science and God
          • How Science and Religion Think
          • The New Atheism
          • Limits of Science
        • Mystery of Existence
          • Back
          • All Mystery of Existence
          • The Mystery of Existence
          • The Mystery of Laws & Cosmos
          • Metaphysics of Cosmos
          • Why Anything at All?
      • LifeJoin our in-depth exploration of life on planet earth and beyond.
        • Back
        • All Life
        • Philosophy of Biology
          • Back
          • All Philosophy of Biology
          • Why Philosophy of Biology?
          • Philosophy of Evolutionary Biology
          • Philosophy of Genes and Information
          • Philosophy of Evolution and Religion
        • What is Life?
          • Back
          • All What is Life?
          • What is Life?
          • What is Death?
        • Human Biology
          • Back
          • All Human Biology
          • Human Nature & Uniqueness
          • Evolutionary Culture and Ethics
          • Sex and Gender
          • Biology of Race
          • Medicine and Healthcare
          • Biological Futures
        • Life in the Cosmos
          • Back
          • All Life in the Cosmos
          • Life in the Cosmos
        • Biological Concepts
          • Back
          • All Biological Concepts
          • Mathematics and Biology
          • Deception
          • Plant Sentience
      • ConsciousnessSearch mysteries of mind and individual awareness
        • Back
        • All Consciousness
        • Mind-Body Problems
          • Back
          • All Mind-Body Problems
          • The Mind-Body Problem
          • Brain Structure and Function
          • Brain Explains Mind?
          • Elements of Mind
        • Consciousness
          • Back
          • All Consciousness
          • Mystery of Consciousness
          • Landscape of Consciousness
          • Consciousness as Emergent
          • Consciousness as All Physical?
          • States of Consciousness
          • Sleep and Dreams
          • Purpose of Consciousness?
          • Metaphysics of Consciousness
        • Persons
          • Back
          • All Persons
          • Persons and Selves
          • Personal Identity
          • Life After Death?
          • Souls?
          • Human Uniqueness
          • Creativity
          • Music
          • Epistemology
          • Belief Systems
          • Mind and Society
          • People and Society
        • Free Will
          • Back
          • All Free Will
          • Mystery of Free Will
          • Philosophy of Free Will
          • Free Will and Consciousness
          • Science of Free Will
          • Free Will and Morality
          • Theology of Free Will
        • Extrasensory Perception
          • Back
          • All Extrasensory Perception
          • ESP and New Realities?
          • ESP and the Nonphysical?
        • Art Seeking Understanding
          • Back
          • All Art Seeking Understanding
          • Aesthetic Cognitivism
          • Art and Philosophy
          • Neuroscience/Cognitive Science of Art
          • Neuroscience/Cognitive Science of Music
          • Art and God
          • Art and Religion
          • Art and Culture
          • Mind, Art, Transcendence
          • Art Seeking Understanding Projects
      • MeaningSeek whether God exists through diverse perspectives
        • Back
        • All Meaning
        • Philosophy of Religion
          • Back
          • All Philosophy of Religion
          • Concepts of God
          • Alternative Concepts of God
          • Faith and Belief
          • Conflict Among Religions
          • Philosophy and Analytic Theology
          • Contemporary Theological Engagement
          • How Philosophy Informs Religion
          • Religion Without God
          • Eastern Traditions and the Big Questions
          • Global Philosophy of Religion
        • Existence of God
          • Back
          • All Existence of God
          • Arguing God's Existence
          • Philosophical Arguments For God
          • Experiential Arguments For God
          • Arguments Against God
        • Attributes of God
          • Back
          • All Attributes of God
          • God's Nature?
          • God's Essence?
          • God's Powers?
          • God and Time?
        • God as Creator
          • Back
          • All God as Creator
          • God The Creator?
          • God's Interactions?
          • God's World?
        • Ultimate Destinies
          • Back
          • All Ultimate Destinies
          • God's Knowledge and Future Events?
          • Judgment (Heaven, Hell)?
          • Resurrection?
          • Eschatology (End Times)?
          • Eternal Life?
          • Search for Meaning
  • News
    • All NewsStay up-to-date with the latest from Closer To Truth
    • Book ExcerptsExplore recently authored books from our contributors
    • PerspectivesRead essays and articles from our community
  • About
    • About Closer To TruthWe are a digital-media nonprofit and TV series
    • The TV SeriesWhere to watch on PBS stations nationwide
    • DonateDonate now to keep our content free!
    • Meet the TeamMeet the host and team behind Closer To Truth
    • PartnershipsLearn about our partners and collaborators
    • Support Closer To TruthWays to engage with and support our work
    • PodcastListen on your favorite podcast player
    • StoreBuy official Closer To Truth merchandise
    • YouTubeSubscribe to Closer To Truth on YouTube
  • Donate
Search
  • Login
  • Join
  • Watch
    • EpisodesWatch complete episodes as aired on public television
    • Curated PlaylistsExplore collections of videos curated by our team
    • ProjectsDiscover collaborations with leading institutions
    • ContributorsMeet the greatest thinkers exploring the deepest questions
    • CTT ChatsWatch chats with the brightest minds on the boldest ideas
    • RoundtablesView roundtable discussions from our early years
  • Topics
    • Topic GuideCosmos, Consciousness, Meaning: Join us as we explore the fundamental questions of existence.
    • CosmosExplore cosmology, physics, and the fundamentals of existence
    • ConsciousnessSearch mysteries of mind and individual awareness
    • MeaningSeek whether God exists through diverse perspectives
  • News
    • The Latest
  • About
    • About Closer To TruthWe are a digital-media nonprofit and TV series
    • TV SeriesWhere to watch on PBS stations nationwide
    • Meet the TeamMeet our host and our team
    • DonateDonate now to keep our content free!
    • PartnershipsLearn about CTT’s partners and collaborators
    • Support Closer to TruthWays to engage with and support our work
    • PodcastListen on your favorite podcast player
    • StoreBuy official Closer To Truth merchandise
    • YouTubeSubscribe to Closer To Truth on YouTube
    • FAQLearn about Closer to Truth membership
  • Login
  • Join

video

Topic Series

David Eagleman

  • Watch Next
Cover image for James Hughes on Transhumanism and Personal Identity

James Hughes on Transhumanism and Personal Identity

Cover image for Mark Bailey on Emergence & AI and Algorithmic Complexity

Mark Bailey on Emergence & AI and Algorithmic Complexity

Cover image for Joseph Corabi on a Collapsing Superintelligence

Joseph Corabi on a Collapsing Superintelligence

Cover image for James Hughes on Buddhism and AI

James Hughes on Buddhism and AI

Cover image for Mark Bailey on Morality in the Age of AI

Mark Bailey on Morality in the Age of AI

Cover image for Jonathan Schooler on the Psychology of Artificial Intelligence

Jonathan Schooler on the Psychology of Artificial Intelligence

  • Details
  • Transcripts
    • Share
Featured In

  • How Free Will Probes Mind and Consciousness
Contributors

David Eagleman

David Eagleman is a neuroscientist researching from human perception to legal...
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
David, free will is one of those subjects that can be a probe of what mind is or even the nature of consciousness. It's been very extant in the philosophical literature. Physicists talk about it in terms of determinism and the laws of physics. But neuroscience is where it happens. Neuroscience is, is – explains how we decide things and what it is. So as a neuroscientist, how do you look at free will? How shall we analyze it?
David Eagleman
There are a few camps about free will, so not surprisingly there are supporters and detractors of the existence of free will. Here's why a lot of neurobiologists think there is not free will. It's because when you look in the brain, everything is connected to everything else. All the neurons are being driven by other neurons and they're driving other neurons and so what you have is this vastly complex network but in the end, it's a network, it's mechanical. And what you need for a sort of metaphysical free will is an uncaused causer. You need something else in the system that's changing the dynamic properties of this physical stuff even though it's not connected to it directly.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
Because every physical law is caused by a previous physical law. Something happens and there's a chain of events no matter how complicated it is. Everything has a prior physical cause and has a, a forced result which is deterministic.
David Eagleman
Exactly, that's exactly right. So a lot of neurobiologists will look at the brain and say, there just doesn't seem to be anywhere else to put something in there to for the uncaused causer to happen. Okay so that's why free will might not exist. And of course there are lots of experiments that can show that people will take credit for having come up with ideas even though they didn't. They were manipulated into choosing something and they'll come up with a narrative about why they did it. Those last examples suggest that we can at least be fooled into thinking we chose something freely even though we didn't.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
And that's used to support the deterministic philosophy based on the hard physical cause so now you have some examples that defend that.
David Eagleman
Exactly right. And then of course we have a whole class of examples where people will do things even though they don't want to. So for example if you have Tourette's syndrome, you have involuntary tics, you'll cuss at somebody even though it's the last thing you want to do. So Tourette, people with Tourette's syndrome don't have free won't. They're not able to not do that thing. So you can't look at somebody and say oh well, you know, of course all your choices are – you get to choose them freely. We at least have lots of evidence that stuff happens that's out of our control. So all that is there. Now, why do some people believe we might have free will? Well it's because we certainly feel like we have free will, right? You, you make choices, you make decisions and we would like to think we're not just deterministic beings that are being cranked forward with an algorithm.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
I think I can raise my hand or not, or whatever I want.
David Eagleman
Precisely. So we have that impression. The situation currently is that there is no killer experiment that actually distinguishes these. We don't have something where everyone says oh yeah that's a good experiment. Now we know which answer is correct. I'll tell you my own view on it, which is that when you above a system of sufficient complexity, there is a, there is a very really sense in which that complex system in making choices and deciding. And even if it is deterministic in some way, it's so complex and it incorporates its past experience and makes probabilistic decision making and so on that it essentially indistinguishable from a system that has what we would like to think of as free will.</p>

So as an example, if you imagine the brain like a giant corporation with 100,000 employees. The CEO does not get to just make any sort of wacky decision to go off in a new direction. He or she is bound by the capabilities of the company, the sentiment of the company, what the employees want to do, and likewise the employees can't go off and do stuff on their own. They have nested loops of management and middle management and all the way up to the CEO. It's a giant organism. And that organism reacts to its environment which might be the stock market or the customers in the case of a corporation. This giant organism works its way through the world, reacting to stimuli and making choices. It makes choices. This is that advertising campaign did not work so let's try this other thing. But nobody's really in charge. It involves the whole system.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
Well let, let's follow the analogy – and it's only an analogy I understand that. But a CEO can override the opinions of the corporation. Steve Jobs is an example at Apple, classically. He has dominated and it's his sense of aesthetics which has driven products and fired people, whatever it took to do that. I mean over-rid it. Now, if you apply the analogy, that would mean that the CEO, whatever that is in me, in my brain, in my mind, can do that but when we looked at it from a neuroscience point of view, the first category, there's no CEO.
David Eagleman
Well there is a CEO in the brain in the sense that that is the highest level of abstraction. So at the lowest level you've got all the neurons and the mechanisms that make things happen. You have layers of abstraction on top of that and on top of that so and just like a company with a CEO so that when you think about it –
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
But it's all neurons, it's all connections. It's all the same thing. One, one thing triggering another thing in a perfect concatenation with nothing else coming in.
David Eagleman
That's exactly right but the different levels of the system, even though they are built of neurons, you have different levels of representation on that. In exactly the same way that the company is built of people the whole way up, it's all just people. But you have some people who are sort of looking at things in a real long-term strategy and they're seeing the whole company. You have exactly the same thing going on in the brain. It's mostly your prefrontal cortex which cares about yourself through time, which cares about these other areas in a, it ignores the details and just cares about what is getting accomplished in the outside world.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
OK so just to continue the highest level abstraction in the cerebral cortex prefrontal or wherever it is, is in some case overruling whatever is coming up from the lower levels, that can happen I think. But, but the issue comes up in the, in the CEO, when you have him in a corporation just looking at it as a kind of a dot CEO without, without structure. That dot CEO can make a free-will decision to override the corporation but when we're talking about the CEO in the brain, this enormously complicated prefrontal area, that's neurons itself. That's the same thing going on there. There's no difference. It, it's all pathways and one neuron connecting to another and it's just another network and it's running by its own deterministic system. So your CEO is just as deterministic as, as the whole system.
David Eagleman
I agree with you. I think this may be where the analogy breaks down is that the – so Steve Jobs actually has, we at least we think Steve Jobs might make decisions about things in a free will kind of manner, but in the brain of course it's exactly right that everything is driven by everything else. But it is the case that your prefrontal cortex is responding to outside stimuli, it cares about you in time. About your future and your past and so it can win in certain circumstances over other areas like the limbic system.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
Fair.
David Eagleman
Where your limbic system says, I want to do this right now. I want to eat that cookie and your prefrontal cortex says don't eat it, you're going to get fat, it's unhealthy. You can have an arm wrestle between these parts of the brain, and it's not that anybody is making a free choice. It's like all of your history, your experience leads up to you being a certain kind of person who can resist a cookie.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
I totally agree with that, but what I think you are arguing, your argument leads to is a sophisticated kind of determinism. I don't see any difference.
David Eagleman
Oh agree, no, no I agree, but that's why I think it's analogous to a, the reason it's helpful to think about accompany is because companies are very complicated and they have nested feedback in all levels of the system. But it is still the case that you would look at a company. You look at Nike shoes and you say, yeah Nike shoes makes decisions and navigates its way through the world. It responds to the market. It's essentially like free will, what we would want to be free will, in the sense that it's reactive, it makes choices. It uses probabilistic decision making. And maybe that's the best we can get. But that's good enough.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
But it is not classically what's called libertarian free will. It is, it is, it is a sophisticated kind of determinism. That's the way it sounds to me.
David Eagleman
I mostly agree with you on that. The problem with the libertarian free will is, as I said, it might be that our science is just too young to understand how it could work. But I don't even know that there's a good definition of what it would mean to, to say that we make free choices completely independent of, of anything else or that we have the capacity to do that.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
Well, it would mean some sort of factor that is not caused by the, the neuronal activity that came from the past. Now, if there was something in the neuronal activity at the present that created that, who knows. But there is still a gap in our understanding.
I think we both agree with that.
David Eagleman
Yeah, there is a big gap in the understanding. I just want to know if you would look at Nike the way it navigates itself through the world as a giant organism and say, say that there's anything lacking in its behavior that would make you feel like that it's not making free decisions and it's not responding to its environment in a way that resembles choice and probabilistic decision making.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
I, I would say that a corporation's decision making is, is closer to a, a real free will than I think we can establish in a human being right now in the human brain.
David Eagleman
Really. Why? But, but Nike of course is just responding to its to its environment and it has very complicated decision making all up and down the ladder, but in the end that's exactly what's happening in the brain. You have lots of experience that's given you probabilities on different aspects of how you should behave. You have different parts competing in the brain about what it thinks the right thing to do is, you have very long-term parts. And, and there is this competition at all of the levels and you navigate through the world just like a corporation does.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
Yeah I guess, I guess that the trick would be is that in, in Nike to really get down to it, each of those individual decision points are a human being and I think we're in, in circles and circles.
David Eagleman
But assume the humans don't have free will in Nike, the employees of Nike are just like us in that lets say they don't have free will.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
Well then there, then there maybe not free will but it may be masked more easily masked in that case, because it will be the, the key points will be smaller and it becomes like a chaotic system that, that has a – that has more of an illusion of free will than it would really have.
David Eagleman
And I think that's exactly what's going on with us. So Nike has 100,000 employees, we've got a hundred billion employees.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
Billion.
David Eagleman
Exactly. And so what happens is –
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
And ours talk to 10,000 at any one time, not just one or two.
David Eagleman
Exactly right. So what happens is the system is so sufficiently complex and it does probabilistic choice, and that essentially is indistinguishable from libertarian free will.

Watch Next

Cover image for James Hughes on Transhumanism and Personal Identity

James Hughes Ph.D. is the Executive Director of the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, and a bioethicist and sociologist who serves as the Associate Provost for...

video

James Hughes on Transhumanism and Personal Identity

8:02

Watch

Cover image for Mark Bailey on Emergence & AI and Algorithmic Complexity

Dr. Mark Bailey writes about the intersection between artificial intelligence, complexity, and national security. He is an associate professor at the National Intelligence...

video

Mark Bailey on Emergence & AI and Algorithmic Complexity

Classic Chats, CTT Chat

10:32

Watch

Cover image for Joseph Corabi on a Collapsing Superintelligence

Dr. Joseph A. Corabi is a Professor and Chair of the Department of Philosophy at Saint Joseph’s University in Philadelphia. He earned his Ph.D. from Rutgers University and...

video

Joseph Corabi on a Collapsing Superintelligence

Classic Chats, CTT Chat

22:50

Watch

Cover image for James Hughes on Buddhism and AI

James Hughes Ph.D. is the Executive Director of the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, and a bioethicist and sociologist who serves as the Associate Provost for...

video

James Hughes on Buddhism and AI

Classic Chats, CTT Chat

16:23

Watch

Cover image for Mark Bailey on Morality in the Age of AI

Dr. Mark Bailey writes about the intersection between artificial intelligence, complexity, and national security. He is an associate professor at the National Intelligence...

video

Mark Bailey on Morality in the Age of AI

Classic Chats, CTT Chat

11:11

Watch

Cover image for Jonathan Schooler on the Psychology of Artificial Intelligence

Jonathan Schooler is an American psychologist and Distinguished Professor of Psychological and Brain Sciences at the University of California, Santa Barbara, who researches...

video

Jonathan Schooler on the Psychology of Artificial Intelligence

Classic Chats, CTT Chat

23:26

Watch


Become a Member

Get free access to exclusive content and more.

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • Watch on YouTube
  • Find us on PBS
  • Donate
  • Contact Us

Policies Terms © Closer To Truth. All rights reserved Website by Visceral