Skip to content

Like this? Share it!

  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Email
Closer To Truth
  • Watch
    • Seasons & EpisodesWatch complete episodes as aired on public television
    • Curated PlaylistsExplore collections of videos curated by our team
    • ProjectsDiscover collaborations with leading institutions
    • ContributorsMeet the greatest thinkers exploring the deepest questions
    • CTT ChatsWatch candid conversations with the brightest minds on the boldest ideas
    • Roundtable ArchivesView roundtable discussions from our early years
  • Topics
    • Cosmos, Life, Consciousness, Meaning: Explore the fundamental questions of existence.Topic Guide
    • All Topics
      • CosmosExplore cosmology, physics, and the fundamentals of existence
        • Back
        • All Cosmos
        • Deep Laws of Nature
          • Back
          • All Deep Laws of Nature
          • Cosmic Fundamentals
          • Time and Space-Time
          • Quantum Theory
          • Philosophy of Science
          • Complexity and Emergence
          • Mathematics as Fundamental?
          • Information as Fundamental?
          • Universe as Simulation?
          • Deep Discoveries in Science
        • Vast Cosmos
          • Back
          • All Vast Cosmos
          • Cosmic Immensity
          • Cosmic Beginnings
          • Cosmic Structure
          • Multiple Universes (Multiverse)
          • Black Holes, Dark Energy, Dark Matter
        • Our Special Universe
          • Back
          • All Our Special Universe
          • Fine-Tuning of the Universe?
          • Fine-Tuning the Universe for Life & Mind?
          • Breathtaking Universe
          • Alien Intelligences?
          • Far Future of the Universe
        • Breakthroughs
          • Back
          • All Breakthroughs
          • Breakthroughs in Science
          • Breakthroughs in Mathematics
        • Science and Religion
          • Back
          • All Science and Religion
          • Science vs. Religion?
          • Science and God
          • How Science and Religion Think
          • The New Atheism
          • Limits of Science
        • Mystery of Existence
          • Back
          • All Mystery of Existence
          • The Mystery of Existence
          • The Mystery of Laws & Cosmos
          • Metaphysics of Cosmos
          • Why Anything at All?
      • LifeJoin our in-depth exploration of life on planet earth and beyond.
        • Back
        • All Life
        • Philosophy of Biology
          • Back
          • All Philosophy of Biology
          • Why Philosophy of Biology?
          • Philosophy of Evolutionary Biology
          • Philosophy of Genes and Information
          • Philosophy of Evolution and Religion
        • What is Life?
          • Back
          • All What is Life?
          • What is Life?
          • What is Death?
        • Human Biology
          • Back
          • All Human Biology
          • Human Nature & Uniqueness
          • Evolutionary Culture and Ethics
          • Sex and Gender
          • Biology of Race
          • Medicine and Healthcare
          • Biological Futures
        • Life in the Cosmos
          • Back
          • All Life in the Cosmos
          • Life in the Cosmos
        • Biological Concepts
          • Back
          • All Biological Concepts
          • Mathematics and Biology
          • Deception
          • Plant Sentience
      • MindSearch mysteries of mind and individual awareness
        • Back
        • All Mind
        • Mind-Body Problems
          • Back
          • All Mind-Body Problems
          • The Mind-Body Problem
          • Brain Structure and Function
          • Brain Explains Mind?
          • Elements of Mind
        • Consciousness
          • Back
          • All Consciousness
          • Mystery of Consciousness
          • Landscape of Consciousness
          • Consciousness as Emergent
          • Consciousness as All Physical?
          • States of Consciousness
          • Sleep and Dreams
          • Purpose of Consciousness?
          • Metaphysics of Consciousness
        • Persons
          • Back
          • All Persons
          • Persons and Selves
          • Personal Identity
          • Life After Death?
          • Souls?
          • Human Uniqueness
          • Creativity
          • Music
          • Epistemology
          • Belief Systems
          • Mind and Society
          • People and Society
        • Free Will
          • Back
          • All Free Will
          • Mystery of Free Will
          • Philosophy of Free Will
          • Free Will and Consciousness
          • Science of Free Will
          • Free Will and Morality
          • Theology of Free Will
        • Extrasensory Perception
          • Back
          • All Extrasensory Perception
          • ESP and New Realities?
          • ESP and the Nonphysical?
        • Art Seeking Understanding
          • Back
          • All Art Seeking Understanding
          • Aesthetic Cognitivism
          • Art and Philosophy
          • Neuroscience/Cognitive Science of Art
          • Neuroscience/Cognitive Science of Music
          • Art and God
          • Art and Religion
          • Art and Culture
          • Mind, Art, Transcendence
          • Art Seeking Understanding Projects
      • MeaningSeek whether God exists through diverse perspectives
        • Back
        • All Meaning
        • Philosophy of Religion
          • Back
          • All Philosophy of Religion
          • Concepts of God
          • Alternative Concepts of God
          • Faith and Belief
          • Conflict Among Religions
          • Philosophy and Analytic Theology
          • Contemporary Theological Engagement
          • How Philosophy Informs Religion
          • Religion Without God
          • Eastern Traditions and the Big Questions
          • Global Philosophy of Religion
        • Existence of God
          • Back
          • All Existence of God
          • Arguing God's Existence
          • Philosophical Arguments For God
          • Experiential Arguments For God
          • Arguments Against God
        • Attributes of God
          • Back
          • All Attributes of God
          • God's Nature?
          • God's Essence?
          • God's Powers?
          • God and Time?
        • God as Creator
          • Back
          • All God as Creator
          • God The Creator?
          • God's Interactions?
          • God's World?
        • Ultimate Destinies
          • Back
          • All Ultimate Destinies
          • God's Knowledge and Future Events?
          • Judgment (Heaven, Hell)?
          • Resurrection?
          • Eschatology (End Times)?
          • Eternal Life?
          • Search for Meaning
  • News
    • All NewsStay up-to-date with the latest from Closer To Truth
    • Book ExcerptsExplore recently authored books from our contributors
    • PerspectivesRead essays and articles from our community
  • About
    • About Closer To TruthWe are a digital-media nonprofit and TV series
    • The TV SeriesWhere to watch on PBS stations nationwide
    • DonateDonate now to keep our content free!
    • Meet the TeamMeet the host and team behind Closer To Truth
    • PartnershipsLearn about our partners and collaborators
    • Support Closer To TruthWays to engage with and support our work
    • PodcastListen on your favorite podcast player
    • StoreBuy official Closer To Truth merchandise
    • YouTubeSubscribe to Closer To Truth on YouTube
  • Donate
Search
  • Login
  • Join
  • Watch
    • EpisodesWatch complete episodes as aired on public television
    • Curated PlaylistsExplore collections of videos curated by our team
    • ProjectsDiscover collaborations with leading institutions
    • ContributorsMeet the greatest thinkers exploring the deepest questions
    • CTT ChatsWatch chats with the brightest minds on the boldest ideas
    • RoundtablesView roundtable discussions from our early years
  • Topics
    • Topic GuideCosmos, Consciousness, Meaning: Join us as we explore the fundamental questions of existence.
    • CosmosExplore cosmology, physics, and the fundamentals of existence
    • MindSearch mysteries of mind and individual awareness
    • MeaningSeek whether God exists through diverse perspectives
  • News
    • The Latest
  • About
    • About Closer To TruthWe are a digital-media nonprofit and TV series
    • TV SeriesWhere to watch on PBS stations nationwide
    • Meet the TeamMeet our host and our team
    • DonateDonate now to keep our content free!
    • PartnershipsLearn about CTT’s partners and collaborators
    • Support Closer to TruthWays to engage with and support our work
    • PodcastListen on your favorite podcast player
    • StoreBuy official Closer To Truth merchandise
    • YouTubeSubscribe to Closer To Truth on YouTube
    • FAQLearn about Closer to Truth membership
  • Login
  • Join

video

Topic Series

David Wallace

  • Watch Next
Cover image for Can Philosophy Discern Sex and Gender?

Can Philosophy Discern Sex and Gender?

Cover image for What Does Transhumanism Foreshadow?

What Does Transhumanism Foreshadow?

Cover image for Evolution vs. Religion: Anything New?

Evolution vs. Religion: Anything New?

Cover image for How did Cognition and Emotion Evolve?

How did Cognition and Emotion Evolve?

Cover image for Big Questions in Free Will Documentary

Big Questions in Free Will Documentary

Cover image for What is Human Nature?

What is Human Nature?

  • Details
  • Transcripts
  • Formats
    • Share
Featured In

  • Physics of Consciousness
Contributors

David Wallace

David Wallace works on philospphy of physics, multi-world interpretation of quantum...
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
David, as a philosopher of physics, what do you think of the efforts of recent times, particularly here at the FQXI conference, to elicit advanced ideas in physics, particularly quantum physics and different structures, to explain consciousness as being something other than the, just the simple biological emergence of what happens macroscopically among neurons in the brain.
David Wallace
Sure. It's always kind of difficult because some of the smartest people I know and some pretty good friends take these approaches very seriously. I find it very difficult to take it seriously at all. It seems that we don't think we need a fundamental physics of digestion or fundamental physics of respiration, even though these are difficult biological processes that we're really lacking a root for. Consciousness people seem to think is different and the reasons they think it's different, I think, are intuitions and hunches, which can feel very plausible, but when you really interrogate them, are hard to sustain.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
Well, I think it's obvious that, as one famous philosopher said, the consciousness is an output of the brain as urine is an output of the kidney. Now, the difference is, and it's very complicated how the kidney filters and all of that, and the other organs as well. The difference is the phenomenological inner movie, the inner subjectivity that we all know that I have, as an individual, and I infer that you do, but you know, I can never know that you could be…everybody else in this world could be an inner zombie, as we say, and I could be the only one conscious. We'll never know that. But that phenomenon is a radical difference, isn't it?
David Wallace
Well, you say that. You've passionately made that case, but assuming that this consciousness is not actually kicking the electrons and atoms around your brain, and almost no one thinks it is, then you'd have made just as passionate the case, just as convincing if you're one of these zombies.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
No. For certain, that's absolutely true, but that argument can be utilized that, because I'm knowing it myself, therefore, and anybody else, and you could envision a zombie doing that for exactly the reason that you said. Therefore, there has to be something else. That argument is used exactly the reverse.
David Wallace
I don't think you can envisage it. I mean, what you're doing when you're envisaging it is you've got a sort of picture in your mind of a person or a robot or whatever and then you're just thinking to yourself, well, that's not conscious, but you don't know that. I mean, by analogy, and this is an analogy of Dan Dennett's, but I could imagine a cell that wasn't alive. Here's me doing it now. I'm imaging a cell, vivid detail, then I'm thinking this cell isn't alive, but that doesn't really mean that I've imagined an un-alive cell. I just haven't thought enough about it. It turns out, if you think really hard about how that cell works, it's living.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
You made a point that, and seemed to think it was self-evident, which to me it's not, that consciousness can't interact. That's one of a whole series of theories of consciousness and philosophy of mind, that consciousness in an epiphenomenon, that it sort of is the foam on the wave. It doesn't cause anything, but it just rides along the surface. That's just one theory. It may be right, but you can't dismiss all the other theories.
David Wallace
Well, let's try it. Let's suppose that there really was a new substance, a consciousnessite, which is not described at all by any physicality we have so far, but actually, when we look really hard at the brain, we find that our – we get a much better theory if we recognize that the electrons are being pushed around by the consciousnessite and we do lots of experiments to support this. Okay, fine. Now somebody comes along and says I can imagine somebody whose brain is just the same and had all the same consciousnessite, but wasn't conscious, and then the question just goes to one regress further. Anything that we're describing in the language of interactions and dynamics is equally open to this objection that says, well, I can imagine all that going on without consciousness. So if you think that objection works, you don't really improve things by supposing there's an interaction.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
Okay, but you're, I think you're still left with the primary problem, which is the phenomenal, phenomenology of what we feel and see being a step function different, being a radical difference from everything else we know in the universe.
David Wallace
How is it different?
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
It's different because if I, if I stub my toe and we see lots of spikes along the C fibers that go to a certain part of my brain, that's one thing and my intense feeling of pain, and knowing what it's like to feel that is a radically different thing. Now, you can correlate them perfectly and that's why many people have come up with an identity theory, which in a sense is a perfect scientific answer, but it seems conceptually absurd to say that my pain is this. They're correlated, but the feeling of the pain versus just seeing sodium ions and potassium ions going through membranes and all that, I mean, it's radically different categories.
David Wallace
We have a really deep intuition that these are radically different, and I share that intuition. What I don't think we have is anything that goes beyond that intuition. We don't have an argument. We don't have a deduction that says these are not the same things and attempts to get it just mean more intuitions come up and I just don't think intuitions are a great route to truth in science. Lots of things are really counterintuitive. It's really, really counterintuitive that your pain literally is a whole bunch of electrical, structural, and functional goings-on in the brain, but the fact is not counterintuitive, that it's counterintuitive doesn't make it false.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
So, what…what…the conclusion of what you would say is that we live in a universe, in a structure of existence, where it is possible for electrical activities to literally be the feeling of consciousness?
David Wallace
I don't think we live in a universe where it's possible; I think we live in a universe where it's actual.
  • Short Video
  • Long Video

Watch Next

Cover image for Can Philosophy Discern Sex and Gender?

Sexual questions abound. What is “normal” sexual behavior in light of diverse sexual variations? LGBTQ+ issues? Is sex in animal models relevant for human sexuality? A...

video

Can Philosophy Discern Sex and Gender?

Episode 7

Season 27

26:47

Watch

Cover image for What Does Transhumanism Foreshadow?

Humanity’s future is now framed by artificial intelligence (AI) and increasing interventions in the body to enhance features and functions. This is transhumanism....

video

What Does Transhumanism Foreshadow?

Episode 8

Season 25

26:47

Watch

Cover image for Evolution vs. Religion: Anything New?

Two kinds of questions probe evolution vs. religion. The first explores discrepancies, even contradictions, between the science of evolution and the beliefs of religion. The...

video

Evolution vs. Religion: Anything New?

Episode 6

Season 27

26:47

Watch

Cover image for How did Cognition and Emotion Evolve?

What can evolution reveal about the developmental history of thinking and feeling? How did cognition and emotion (affect) co-develop over evolutionary time? Can evolution...

video

How did Cognition and Emotion Evolve?

Episode 5

Season 27

26:47

Watch

Cover image for Big Questions in Free Will Documentary

Do we have free will? After so many centuries of debate by so many great thinkers, can we still make progress in answering this question? That’s the goal of the Big...

video

Big Questions in Free Will Documentary

1:37:06

Watch

Cover image for What is Human Nature?

What is “human” nature? While human beings are animals, we believe we are special, radically different from other animals. Why? What traits are unique to humans? Are we...

video

What is Human Nature?

Episode 4

Season 27

26:47

Watch


Become a Member

Get free access to exclusive content and more.

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • Watch on YouTube
  • Find us on PBS
  • Donate
  • Contact Us

Policies Terms © Closer To Truth. All rights reserved Website by Visceral